Ecumenical Patriarch: Against violence in Magdeburg but for it in Cherkasy?
Epifaniy Dumenko and Patriarch Bartholomew. Photo: RBC Ukraine
"The Ecumenical Patriarchate firmly condemns all forms of violence, regardless of their origin. It prays for the repose of the souls of innocent victims, the full recovery of the injured, and the comfort of their loved ones plunged into mourning, pain, and sorrow," the Patriarch said.
And he is undoubtedly right. So why are we mentioning this?
Because when in Ukraine, members of the OCU commit acts of violence during the seizure of UOC churches, Patriarch Bartholomew remains silent. Consider, for example, the events in Cherkasy. In November 2023, OCU militants in camouflage seized the Nativity of the Virgin Monastery. During the attack, Father Sergiy Pashchenko had his jaw broken in two places, and an elderly parishioner suffered a broken leg. In October 2024, there was an even more violent seizure of the cathedral, where Metropolitan Theodosiy sustained a concussion after being struck on the head with a baton, and worshippers were shot with non-lethal weapons inside the church.
It is important to note that Patriarch Bartholomew has no ability to influence Islamist actions in Germany. However, he could certainly influence the actions of OCU militant believers. Moreover, had he condemned "all forms of violence" by the OCU in 2023, the "Cherkasy brawl" of 2024 might not have occurred. Neither would there have been violence in hundreds of other cases across Ukraine.
We realize that Patriarch Bartholomew is reluctant to admit the banditry of his protégés, as doing so would significantly damage his credibility. Yet, he will have no choice but to address it someday. This ostrich-like tactic of burying one's head in the sand has long lost its effectiveness.
Read also
Why do the people love Patriarch Ilia so deeply?
What people truly long for is not simply a leader, but a man who stands before God on their behalf – one through whom the light of the divine presence quietly, unmistakably shines. This is the one thing people await from a first hierarch above all else.
Why did no one come for Filaret?
When Filaret – who had been “reinstated in his rank” – died, not a single bishop from any Local Church came to his funeral.
Is this the end of the Kyiv Patriarchate?
The UOC-KP is not protesting the fact that its head will be buried by the OCU.
"Potemkin" monks of the Lavra
Outside the capital, the OCU has around 120 monks. At the same time, it claims more than 80 monasteries. The arithmetic is simple: on average, each “monastery” has one and a half inhabitants.
The UGCC “сan survive persecution” – unless it happens to someone else
The current situation surrounding the UOC is no different from what the Uniates themselves experienced after the Lviv Council.