Amsterdam on Met Arseniy case: An unspeakable level of cruelty and torture

Metropolitan Arseniy in the hospital. Photo: Sviatohirsk Lavra
In an interview with journalist Tucker Carlson, international lawyer Robert Amsterdam, who documents violations of believers’ rights in Ukraine, described in detail the case of Metropolitan Arseniy of Sviatohirsk. According to the lawyer, the situation in which the hierarch has found himself reflects an indescribable level of cruelty and torture.
Amsterdam said that one of his lawyers had visited Metropolitan Arseniy in a prison located in an active combat zone. The hierarch has been held in custody for 17 months despite his grave health condition. “He has no stomach. He is horribly ill. He is a monk, a bishop who has devoted his life to the Church,” the lawyer noted.
Amsterdam explained that after a long period of detention, there had been expectations that Metropolitan Arseniy would be released at least on medical grounds. However, after a brief release from the pre-trial detention center, the hierarch was once again seized by Ukrainian security services.
“They get him out for a moment – and then the secret police arrest him, and he is incarcerated again. It is a level of cruelty and torture that I cannot even express to you,” said the international attorney.
The lawyer highlighted that the new charge brought against the bishop allegedly concerns “resistance to the Russian invasion,” but, as Amsterdam stated, it is entirely trumped up and bogus.
Robert Amsterdam also stressed that the case of Metropolitan Arseniy fits into a broader pattern of persecution against the Ukrainian Orthodox Church – a situation, he said, that the general public in the West is completely unfamiliar with.
As previously reported by the UOJ, Amsterdam noted that although Western media have begun to shift their attitudes toward President Zelensky, the issue of repression against believers, the seizure of churches, and the actions of Ukrainian security forces against the UOC remain entirely suppressed.
Read also
Volodymyr-Volynskyi Eparchy marks 30 years since restoration
The Pantanassa Icon and relics of Prince Volodymyr have arrived in Kovel and will visit churches across the Volodymyr-Volynskyi Eparchy to mark the 30th anniversary of the restoration of the episcopal see.
Bukovyna faithful bring humanitarian aid to Kherson region residents
The UOC’s Chernivtsi Eparchy delivered food to Holy Spirit Cathedral in Kherson.
Ukraine must have its own faith: Poroshenko's party lays out peace terms
Poroshenko’s party European Solidarity described church policy as a matter of national sovereignty and said there can be no compromises in this area.
432 UOC churches damaged in Ukraine during war, report says
According to the Religion on Fire project, 807 religious buildings in Ukraine have been damaged or destroyed as a result of hostilities.
DESS official gives number of clergy exempt from mobilization in Ukraine
A DESS representative said the actual number of clergy exempt from mobilization is significantly lower than the number of religious organizations designated as critical.
Cabinet keeps gas prices unchanged for religious organizations
The Cabinet has fixed gas prices for religious organizations through the end of the 2026–2027 heating season.