Amsterdam: Metropolitan Arseniy's case is a full-scale crime against humanity
Robert Amsterdam. Photo: Piers Morgan’s YouTube channel
On December 1, 2025, the London-based law firm Amsterdam & Partners LLP released a statement concerning the case against Metropolitan Arseniy of Sviatohirsk, accusing the Ukrainian authorities of fabrication and systematic attacks on believers. Another court hearing in the cleric’s case is scheduled for tomorrow.
The statement notes that the UOC hierarch has been held in harsh conditions for more than a year. He is accused of disclosing the location of the Ukrainian army after he spoke out against road checkpoints that prevented UOC parishioners from reaching the churches of the Sviatohirsk Lavra. According to the human-rights defenders, the charges were brought months after the sermon, and the checkpoints mentioned in it were never subjected to enemy shelling.
“The imprisonment of this innocent monk is part of the Ukrainian government's ongoing violations of religious freedom,” the statement says. According to the attorneys, the Ukrainian authorities are aggressively pursuing a policy of promoting the state-backed Orthodox Church of Ukraine (OCU) at the expense of the UOC, resulting in the forcible transfer of parishes from one confession to another.
The human-rights advocates remind readers that in August 2024 Ukraine adopted Law No. 3894, establishing a legal basis for banning the UOC. The law was condemned by the Vatican, Pope Francis, the World Council of Churches, Human Rights Watch, and the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights.
Robert Amsterdam, founder and managing partner of Amsterdam & Partners LLP, reiterated: “The authorities' conduct in relation the UOC, of which Metropolitan Arseniy's case is emblematic, involves a full-scale crime against humanity. This crime is being committed by President Zelensky and by others involved in state-organized systematic attacks on civilians for their membership in the UOC.”
Amsterdam called on the international community to take note of “the shameful and merciless theatre of the absurd that is going on throughout the Ukrainian courts, orchestrated by the Ukrainian secret police – the SBU.”
Earlier, the UOJ quoted Amsterdam as saying that one cannot speak of democracy in Ukraine while clergy are being tortured.
Read also
Medieval сhurch сrumbles as Culture Ministry сites missing agreement
The 14th–15th-century St. Nicholas Church in Chesnyky, Ivano-Frankivsk Region, is falling into disrepair.
Poland сondemns Lviv Regional Council's decision to declare 2007 year of UPA
Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk says the Lviv Regional Council's decision to dedicate 2027 to the UPA and Roman Shukhevych is harmful to Ukraine.
OCU seeks court recognition of ownership of seized Cherkasy cathedral
The Cherkasy Regional Commercial Court will hear an OCU lawsuit seeking ownership of St. Michael's Cathedral, which was seized from UOC believers.
Lithuanian bishop: Ukraine is no model for believers' rights
Vicar of Vilnius Diocese voices concern over attempts to import Ukraine's religious conflict into Lithuania.
Hundreds of believers honor St. Alexis of Carpatho-Russia in Khust Eparchy
At the St. Nicholas Monastery in the village of Iza-Karputlash, Metropolitan Mark of Khust led a festive liturgy, concelebrated by six metropolitans, five archbishops and three bishops.
Court upholds UOC parish appeal in Voloshky over OCU switch dispute
The Northern Commercial Court of Appeal has upheld the appeal of the St. Nicholas parish of the UOC in the village of Voloshky, Volyn region, in a dispute over a transfer to the OCU.