Bill 8371 does not comply with Ukraine's international obligations
Photo: a screenshot from the website forum18.org
Bill 8371 on banning the UOC does not meet Ukraine's international human rights obligations to respect and protect the freedoms of religion or belief, expression, and association, says the article published on the website of the Norwegian human rights organisation Forum 18 on 6 March 2024.
The author of the article, Dmytro Vovk, a visiting professor at the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law and managing director of the Centre for the Rule of Law and Religion Studies at the Yaroslav the Wise National Law University in Ukraine, and a lecturer in law at the Ukrainian Catholic University gives a thorough legal analysis of the bill.
"The adoption of the bill in its current wording indicates that the Ukrainian state has decided to deal harshly with the UOC," the author emphasises. “In addition to prosecuting clerics, believers and communities involved in security offences, the state will prosecute all UOC communities for ecclesiastical and historical ties with the Russian Orthodox Church."
In his opinion, this will legitimise the large-scale and relatively quick stripping of the legal status of all UOC communities.
"This will both legitimise past decisions by local councils in some regions to strip UOC communities of the right to lease land or property and will force UOC organisations to abandon several state-owned historically significant places of worship, such as Pochaiv Lavra in Ternopil region," he concludes.
According to Professor D. Vovk's analysis, the draft law will also significantly increase the state's role in inter-religious relations and expand the powers of the DESS to monitor and control religious communities and the expression of religious ideas. Such an expansion of powers, the author is sure, will not have sufficient legal protection against their arbitrary use.
"Without carefully addressing these issues, the draft law will not be able to implement Ukraine's legally binding international obligations to respect and protect freedom of religion or belief, freedom of expression and association," the expert stresses.
The Norwegian publication Forum 18 informs that several international organisations are ready to draw up their expert opinion on the draft law but they have not received any requests from the Ukrainian authorities.
"The OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) has not received a request from the Ukrainian authorities to review the Bill, ODIHR spokesperson Katja Andrusz told Forum 18 that it had not received a request to review the draft law."
As previously reported, the UOC could be banned based on Russian documents
Read also
Kosovo to enact law restricting Serbian Church, experts say
Analysts warn that the new "Law on Foreigners" in Kosovo could restrict the presence of clergy, believers' access to shrines, and increase pressure on the Serbian community.
Congress Speaker: Demand to introduce Sharia law in USA is a serious problem
The Speaker of the House of Representatives stated that there is growing concern in society about attempts to impose Islamic law, which is incompatible with the American Constitution.
UK government introduces restrictions on "anti-Muslim hostility"
UK authorities have adopted a new definition of "Islamophobia" which, according to experts, could provide Muslims with special protection and restrict freedom of speech.
Dumenko brings icon in Church Slavonic to Ministry of Health
Epifaniy presented cardiologists with an Intercession icon, with inscriptions in Church Slavonic, which his structure calls a "sign of the Moscow tradition".
ISIS supporters carries out terrorist attack at anti-Islamic protest in NY
Near the home of New York's Muslim mayor, radicals threw two makeshift bombs at protesters during an anti-Islamic rally.
Hryshchuk: If UOC hands over its church itself, angle grinders aren't needed
An OCU chaplain called on UOC believers to accept the loss of the shrine for the sake of their own "enlightenment".