“Tsarist” cathedral: Ukraine’s heritage or the “empire of evil”?

Today 22:13
16
St. Volodymyr's Cathedral in the early 20th century. Photo: open sources St. Volodymyr's Cathedral in the early 20th century. Photo: open sources

Why does the OCU want churches associated with the “Russian World”?

On November 19, another falling Russian drone damaged windows at the Austrian and Dutch embassies, as well as at St. Volodymyr's Cathedral in Kyiv.

In response, Culture Minister T. Berezhna issued a statement calling the cathedral "our cultural heritage," which Russia "continues to destroy." Meanwhile, OCU spokesman Y. Zoria declared that the "Russian empire of evil has struck another of our holy sites."

There is no question that the destruction of churches is terrible. But there is another issue worth discussing here. Berezhna stated that the cathedral's murals were painted by "renowned artists Mikhail Vrubel, Nikolai Pymonenko, Serhiy Kostenko, Viktor Zamirailo, and others."

The culture minister's statement is deeply puzzling because it is common knowledge that the cathedral's principal murals were painted by Viktor Vasnetsov, while Mikhail Nesterov completed a substantial portion of the work. Individual Gospel scenes were painted by Pavel and Alexander Svedomsky and Wilhelm Kotarbiński. The artists named by Berezhna either served as assistants or worked on decorative ornamentation. Kostenko, for example, painted "The Baptism of Vladimir" and "The Last Judgment" based on Vasnetsov's sketches.

Why, then, did the culture minister present such a distorted account of the cathedral's artistic history? One might speculate that it has something to do with Vasnetsov and Nesterov, who were particularly close to the Russian imperial court. But what does this manipulation accomplish? After all, St. Volodymyr's Cathedral was an imperial project from the very beginning. Nicholas I approved it, Alexander II ordered construction to continue, and Nicholas II attended its consecration and personally met with Vasnetsov.

So we would like to ask the culture minister and the OCU leadership: Is the "Tsarist" St. Volodymyr's Cathedral still "our cultural heritage," or is it no longer?

And St. Volodymyr's Cathedral in Kyiv is hardly the only example. The OCU's Resurrection Cathedral in Rivne was founded by Alexander III and built with state treasury funds. That did not prevent Epifaniy Dumenko from solemnly celebrating the cathedral's 130th anniversary last year. We might also recall Holy Trinity Cathedral in Lutsk, St. Andrew's Church in Kyiv, St. Volodymyr's Chapel in Volodymyr, and many other churches built or reconstructed at the initiative and expense of Russian tsars.

If the OCU and the authorities are so embarrassed by their "Russian" history and so determined to eradicate every mention of it, why go to all this trouble? After all, Dumenko himself has repeatedly said that the OCU rejects everything Russian, including church architecture. So why do our bright-eyed elves need all this heritage of the "empire of evil"?

After all, there are people in Ukraine whom the OCU calls "Muscovites" and "spiritual occupiers." These people are not ashamed of their ancestors' heritage, nor do they paint it black simply because a war is underway.

So there is a very simple solution: hand the "imperial" churches over to the "FSB agents." Let them admire the frescoes by Vasnetsov and Nesterov in St. Volodymyr's Cathedral, or those by Vrubel in St. Cyril's Church. And build something of your own instead.

Then the culture minister would no longer have to hastily "forget" the wrong icon painters.

If you notice an error, select the required text and press Ctrl+Enter or Submit an error to report it to the editors.
If you find an error in the text, select it with the mouse and press Ctrl+Enter or this button If you find an error in the text, highlight it with the mouse and click this button The highlighted text is too long!
Read also