UOC Legal Dept: Claims of Upper Lavra dispute resolution premature
The UOC Legal Department said it intends to challenge the ruling on the churches of the Upper Kyiv Caves Lavra in the Supreme Court.
The Legal Department of the UOC commented on the decision of the Northern Commercial Court of Appeal in the case concerning the Dormition Cathedral and the Refectory Church of the Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra and called premature the statements by certain representatives of the state authorities that the court process has supposedly been finally concluded.
The Synodal Department noted that an appellate review does not exhaust the lawful means of judicial protection, so after receiving the full text of the court ruling, the lawyers will prepare a cassation appeal to the Supreme Court.
The UOC also recalled that "the state's right to dispose of property is not a right to arbitrarily restrict the freedom of religious activity. State ownership does not release state bodies from the obligation to observe the law, contractual obligations, and constitutional guarantees of human rights." The lawyers stressed that the defense of the rights of the Lavra brethren will continue in both national and international legal bodies.
The department also expressed serious concern about both the verdict itself and the gross procedural violations with which the hearing was conducted. In particular, the monks involved in the case as third parties did not even receive proper notification of the date and time of the hearing, and the monastery's lawyers were not given the opportunity to fully state the grounds for recusing the judges before the refusal was issued.
The judges spent exactly five minutes familiarizing themselves with the 30 volumes of the case, comprising about 7,500 pages. At the same time, the monastery's defenders were given only one minute each to orally substantiate extensive written motions.
The hearing also took place in an atmosphere of pressure: listeners present in the courtroom shouted insults and made unsubstantiated accusations against UOC representatives. The judges did not react in any way to the lawyers' requests to restore order in the courtroom, so the defenders had to to leave the hearing, describing what was happening as a denial of the right to a full defense.
"Court proceedings cannot be reduced to a formal hearing of the parties' positions and the proclamation of a predictably expected result," the UOC Legal Department emphasized. "The court is obliged to ensure that every participant in the case has a real, not merely declarative, opportunity to be heard."
Earlier, the UOJ reported that the court rejected the appeal of the UOC monastery in the Upper Lavra case.

