Dumenko asks Phanar to strip Russian Church head of patriarchal title
The OCU believes that Patriarch Kirill preaches the heresy of ethnophyletism, and that some decisions of the Holy Synod of the ROC do not conform to the principles of Orthodox ecclesiology.
On July 27, 2022, Epiphany Dumenko, at the behest of the "synod" of the OCU, sent a letter to Patriarch Bartholomew about bringing the Primate of the ROC, Patriarch Kirill, to canonical accountability and depriving him of the patriarchate, reports the official website of the Dumenko structure.
Dumenko asked the head of the Phanar to "initiate, at the pan-Orthodox level, consideration and condemnation of the activity of Moscow Patriarch Kirill Gundyaev and of the ethnophyletist and racist teaching of the 'Russian world' that he preaches."
Epiphany emphasized that "Russia is a country that for centuries has linked its identity with Orthodoxy," but that "over recent decades the Christian faith in Russia has been subjected to paganization – insidiously replaced by a civil religion that relies on the Orthodox tradition but is alien to the spirit of the Gospel and to the content of the patristic Orthodox faith."
In the opinion of the head of the OCU, moral responsibility for the crimes committed by Russian soldiers in Ukraine "falls not only on the direct perpetrators but also on their ideological inspirers – Moscow Patriarch Kirill and like-minded hierarchs who for decades have propagated the ethnophyletist and racist teaching of the 'Russian world.'"
The head of the OCU believes that "Metropolitan, and subsequently Patriarch, Kirill has never been a model of the confession of the Orthodox faith," and recalled that as far back as March 15 of this year, on the Sunday of Orthodoxy, the Declaration on the "Russian world" was made public, which was initially signed by more than 340 Orthodox theologians from various countries of the world, a number that has now grown to one thousand.
The Declaration states that the "Russian world" is a non-Orthodox, heretical doctrine, akin to the teaching of ethnophyletism, condemned at the Council of Constantinople in 1872.
He also drew the attention of the head of the Phanar to the "Open Appeal to the Primates of the Orthodox Churches," signed by 437 clergymen of the UOC, and accused the ROC of racism.
"Beginning at least in October 2018, all the actions of Patriarch Kirill have been subordinated to a specific political goal. He seeks to radically increase the presence of the ROC outside Russia, to weaken the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Greek-speaking Local Churches as much as possible, and thereby to impose on the Orthodox world the hegemony and dictate of the Moscow Patriarch," Dumenko writes.
He called on the head of the Phanar "to examine as quickly as possible the activity of Patriarch Kirill connected with his opposition to the Ecumenical Patriarchate and to many Local Orthodox Churches, and should this activity be found to contain signs of schism, – to bring the Patriarch to canonical accountability."
He also asked Patriarch Bartholomew "to canonically qualify several decisions of the Holy Synod of the Russian Orthodox Church, adopted during 2018-2021, which, in our opinion, do not correspond to the principles of Orthodox ecclesiology."
In this regard, on behalf of the "hierarchs" of the OCU and the "numerous victims of Russia's war against Ukraine, which the Patriarch of Moscow openly and unequivocally publicly approves and supports," Dumenko appealed to the head of the Phanar and the Primates of the Local Orthodox Churches with a request to "condemn the doctrine of the 'Russian world' and recognize it as heretical; to qualify the actions of Patriarch Kirill in the canonical territory of the Patriarchate of Alexandria as schismatic; to deprive Kirill Gundyaev of the right to occupy the Moscow Patriarchal throne."
Earlier, the UJO reported that more than 400 UOC priests supported an Appeal in which they called for the Patriarch of the ROC to be brought before the tribunal of the "Council of the Eastern Churches".
