"Ecumenism is a temptation of the last days"
What Fr. Peter Heers planned to say in his canceled lecture on Elder Ephraim, where the Ukrainian church crisis has its roots, and who has the authority to make decisions for the entire Church – in an interview with UOJ-Greece.
The Greek editorial office of the Union of Orthodox Journalists publishes an interview with Father Peter Heers, a well-known American theologian and writer.
Fr. Peter was born in the United States to an Anglican priest and converted to Orthodoxy at the age of 20. He is the spiritual son of one of the closest disciples of Elder Ephraim of Arizona, the founder of Orthodox Ethos, and the author of books on ecumenism and the boundaries of the Church. He currently serves as a cleric of the Romanian Orthodox Church’s Metropolia of the Americas.
In this interview, Fr. Peter explains why he considers ecumenism “a temptation of the last days” and discusses the crisis of conciliarity that he sees as the root of the Ukrainian church question. The conversation also explores Elder Ephraim’s legacy, Church decisions during the pandemic, raising children, and his message to young people.
From Arizona – to Elder Ephraim
Thank you for accepting our invitation so readily. You’ve traveled a very long way. Where have you come from?
From America – Arizona, to be precise. We’ve been living there for almost nine years. Before that, I spent nearly 20 years in Greece, from 1998 to 2017. We left in 2017. I taught at Holy Trinity Orthodox Seminary in Jordanville for two years, and then we moved to Arizona. In 2018, we opened a school, the Three Holy Hierarchs Academy, and we’ve been there ever since.
So you live near Elder Ephraim?
Very close. A ten-minute drive.
Glory to God! What is it like to be so close to him?
It’s a tremendous blessing to be near his grave, the places where he walked, and the monastery he built. I first met the elder in 1994, and in 1995 I visited the monastery when there were still only tents and a generator. There was no electricity or running water. The elder was starting from nothing in the middle of the desert.
In 1998, I went to Greece intending to become a monk on Mount Athos, but I always maintained my connection with the elder. I often visited him with my family, and whenever I faced an important decision, I would seek his guidance. So America feels like home to me because of the elder.
Was he your spiritual father?
He was my spiritual father’s spiritual father. But we had direct contact from the very beginning, and whenever I faced a major decision in life, I would travel to Arizona to discuss it with the elder and receive his blessing.
From Anglicanism to Orthodoxy
I know you were born in the United States, into the family of an Anglican priest...
Yes. My father was a priest for 28 years, and in 1992 he and his entire parish became Orthodox. A year later, I became Orthodox as well. I was studying at the University of Wisconsin at the time, and I was 20 years old.
Tell us about your family’s conversion to Orthodoxy – first in general terms, and then about your own experience.
My parents always tried to remain faithful to the tradition they knew and opposed all the innovations in the Anglican Church, especially the ordination of women. After ten years of struggling against these changes, they realized there was no light there and that they needed to look elsewhere.
Then God sent a convert priest who met my father and opened the door to Orthodoxy for him in 1991 – 35 years ago.
Everything happened quickly. Within six months, my father had studied the question, and the entire parish was ready. God had prepared the ground.
I remember my mother calling me at university and saying, “We’re becoming Orthodox.” I asked, “What do you mean? What is Orthodoxy?” I knew almost nothing about it. She replied, “It’s another world.”
Then I went to a local Greek Orthodox parish. I remember attending Vespers in a beautiful, simple little church – almost a chapel by Greek standards. Inside were only the priest, the chanter, and one elderly woman.
But to me, it was as though I had entered paradise. It really was another world, just as my mother had said. I remember the feeling when I closed the door behind me after Vespers: “What was that? It was as though I’d been somewhere else entirely.”
It was nothing like the Roman Catholics. By then, I had already left the Anglican Church and was considering becoming a Latin-rite Catholic because they at least seemed somewhat more faithful to tradition.
My heart accepted Orthodoxy immediately, but my mind needed to follow. I had to read. And God arranged for me to come across Fr. Seraphim Rose’s book Orthodoxy and the Religion of the Future. That’s quite a radical first book for a convert. But one thing struck me: if this man understands the devil and demonic activity so well, then he must also know Christ. He must be enlightened by Christ.
It was so unlike anything I had read before that God immediately set me on the path of traditional Orthodoxy – toward monasticism and everything that followed. I left everything behind and began visiting monasteries throughout America.
Education, Mount Athos, baptism, and priesthood
Before we return to your conversion, tell us a little about your education. What did you study?
I first studied history in America. When I came here, I earned a degree in theology and then completed my master’s and doctoral work in dogmatics under Professor Dimitrios Tselengidis. My subject was the ecclesiology of the Second Vatican Council. The work has been published in both Greek and English.
From the very first moment you enter the Church, ecclesiology confronts you as a convert, whether you want it to or not. You don't merely think about these questions – you live them. How are you received into the Church? Through Baptism or Chrismation? On what grounds? What does it mean?
I have lived with these questions since becoming Orthodox. I wrote my dissertation on the subject, and since then we have written and published many books about it. Because everything revolves around this question: the identity of Christ, the Church, and salvation.
Could we say that the Holy Spirit called you – rang a bell, so to speak? Did you feel it when you returned home and said, “It’s another world”?
Yes. You immediately recognize the difference. The soul understands because the Holy Spirit speaks silently within it. It’s not a matter of analysis or criticism. The heart finds peace. You want to remain there and never leave. There is warmth – the warmth of the Holy Spirit – and you don’t want to move away from it.
Yes. You immediately recognize the difference. The soul understands because the Holy Spirit speaks silently within it. It’s not a matter of analysis or criticism. The heart finds peace. You want to remain there and never leave. There is warmth – the warmth of the Holy Spirit – and you don’t want to move away from it.
Was there someone who helped you hold on to what you had come to believe was the truth during those first steps?
Yes, several people. I was searching, moving from place to place, and two or three people helped me tremendously. One was an elderly hieromonk, Fr. Sergius Black, with whom I spent a year. He had studied under Fr. Georges Florovsky and Archbishop Basil (Krivoshein), and he knew the great figure of the Russian Church, Elder Sophrony. He passed on many wonderful things to me.
Then there was the thousand-page biography of Fr. Seraphim Rose. It changed everything. After reading it, everything became perfectly clear: I wanted to become a monk. In 1996, I traveled to Mount Athos and was baptized there – we’ll come back to that.
Bishop Basil also helped me greatly. We remain close to this day, and I still call him. Then there was another person on Mount Athos, and Elder Ephraim himself, whom my father met in 1994, two years after my parents became Orthodox. So there were quite a few people.
You had accepted the truth, but you continued searching – and rightly so. Was your time on Mount Athos decisive? You wanted to stay there, become a monk, and receive Baptism?
Yes, I wanted to become a monk. I’m not a monk – I never became one, although I wanted to. But that was not my will; it was God’s will. There’s quite a story behind it.
Tell us what happened.
In 1996, I first visited Mount Athos. I went to all 20 monasteries, visited the cells, climbed to the summit, and spent almost two months there. Eventually, I was baptized. In America, I had been received through Chrismation, but the Athonite fathers do not consider that the proper way of receiving converts. Elder Parthenios baptized me at St. Paul’s Monastery. He is a holy man, truly holy, and it was a tremendous honor and blessing for us.
I then returned to America and began publishing a magazine called Divine Ascent. I stayed there for a year, but my heart was on Mount Athos. In 1998, I returned and found my elder, one of Elder Ephraim’s five closest disciples. He played a decisive role in my life. Without him, I don’t know where I would be today.
A spiritual father is the most important person in one’s life – the alpha and omega. I remained in Greece with his blessing. I wanted to become a monk, but he told me, “It would be better for you to become a priest.” Leaving Mount Athos was difficult. I didn’t want to go, but I accepted it as God’s will.
A week later, I met my future wife. We spoke two or three times and decided to get married. I wanted her to become a priest’s wife, while she had been considering monasticism. That also showed you the truth of what the elder had said: if you obey, God will arrange everything.
Yes, everything is blessed, and I believe that too.
That’s exactly what happened. But obedience is difficult. It is a constant struggle. It requires humility, fighting against your own will and your own thoughts. I stayed, enrolled in the theology department, and continued visiting Mount Athos three or four times a year. That was where I learned Orthodoxy. Mount Athos was my school of spiritual life, and that was how I came to study theology.
I wrote my dissertation not because earning a doctorate was my goal, but because I wanted to offer the Church something important. That is why I chose the subject and spent years studying the reception of heretics into the Church. As I said, this is a defining question. It provides the foundation for understanding the boundaries of the Church, her identity, and much more. Glory to God.
The benefits of Orthodoxy: discernment of spirits
What did Peter find in Orthodoxy that had been missing from his former faith?
Life and truth. If you have never lived outside the Church, among the heterodox, you cannot understand this. It is a matter of experience.
Heterodoxy is religion, not revelation. There is no Holy Spirit there, no grace in the sacraments, and no understanding of the discernment of spirits. That is what distinguishes Orthodoxy from everything else: the discernment of spirits.
Behind movements and ideologies are spirits, demons. These are not merely ideas; they also involve the activity of spirits. So when we speak of discerning spirits, we mean not only recognizing demonic activity or presence itself, but also all its consequences – all the movements arising from the fallen world and directed against the salvation of the world and mankind.
Orthodoxy recognizes them. If you struggle spiritually and purify your mind, you begin to see and understand: this comes from God, and that comes from the devil. There are criteria for discerning these things. Outside the Church, those criteria do not exist.
Beyond the answer someone might find in a university textbook, I’d like to ask you as a priest and as a person, for the benefit of those watching us. After all, our audience includes not only Orthodox Christians but also people of other confessions and religions who want to learn, just as you once did. Could you name one or two differences in faith that you personally encountered? You said Orthodoxy is life.
There are many. Everyone knows there are differences in dogma. We can discuss those, but they are not the most important thing. Of course, Western innovations – the Filioque, papal supremacy, and so on – took them far from the faith of the Apostles.
But even before they fell into those errors, they had abandoned the ascetic, hesychastic life.
Historically, I cannot prove that conclusively, but it follows from spiritual laws. From spiritual life, we know that dogma and ethos – the spiritual way of life – are inseparable. When you fall away from the ethos, from the way of life, you also fall away from dogma. It is almost a law.
So before they abandoned the conciliar system and embraced papal supremacy, before accepting the Filioque – a heretical teaching concerning the Holy Trinity and the Holy Spirit – they had already fallen away in their way of life, their ethos, their experience.
And we, too, can make that mistake if we are not strict in our spiritual lives.
Or if we are too strict, I would add. Both extremes.
Yes, both extremes exist today, and I would say they converge in how they operate. They resemble each other because both are worldly. Both are characterized by worldly thinking and rationalism. They may criticize and hate one another, but they actually belong together.
The royal path has nothing to do with either extreme. It is important to understand that unity cannot be achieved simply by “correcting” papal primacy. Anyone who says that is spiritually deluded.
Over the past thousand years, many other things have happened that divide us. Anyone who has traveled the path from Anglicanism or Roman Catholicism to Orthodoxy knows this.
For example, they regard Francis of Assisi as a saint. But if you read his life, it becomes clear that it is not the life of a saint of the Orthodox Church. There are many things there that any elder here would identify as spiritual delusion or misunderstanding.
Let me give just one example out of hundreds: he prayed to Christ to grant him His stigmata. That request alone is already spiritual delusion. You and I may bear the “marks of the Lord” and suffer, even physically, as Christ did, but we must not ask for such things. Yet he asked and received them. And he was not alone. Some 200 other “saints” of the papal church reportedly had bleeding stigmata, right down to Padre Pio, who lived just a few decades ago.
These are signs of spiritual delusion, not holiness. So what kind of unity can there be if we merely “correct” one or two dogmas? It is the worldliness that truly separates us. To sum up, someone coming to Orthodoxy from another confession will understand it through the examples the faith provides – through imitating the saints and living an Orthodox way of life.
Protestantism and “two boats”
Does Protestantism influence Orthodoxy? I mean, many people consider the Protestant way of life easier. Some who are listening to us are somewhere in between. They say, “I can be somewhat Orthodox, even mostly Orthodox, but still do some of the things Protestants do – there’s more freedom there.” Does this affect the thinking of someone who wants to become Orthodox?
A Christian is “not of this world.” He lives in the world but is not of the world. Protestantism is of the world. In other words, such a person wants to live a worldly life. That is impossible. He has two masters. His heart is divided – given both to the world and to God. It cannot work. It cannot last. As the Lord says, he will hate the one and love the other.
You cannot stand in two boats at once. Absolutely not. Most likely, such a person doesn’t really know Orthodoxy yet.
He is halfway there, still searching.
Yes.
The holy fathers and pastoral ministry
In your opinion, do Orthodox Christians in Greece and the United States know the theology of the Holy Fathers and the Ecumenical Councils? Do we – and I include myself first – know which path to follow, at what pace, and for how long? And please tell us more about America.
If we labor spiritually and strive to obey our spiritual father, if we have a good disposition and struggle to examine ourselves and gain self-knowledge, then we will be able to assimilate the teachings of the Holy Fathers, the Ecumenical Councils, and the whole of Tradition. Without that, the door is closed. The books are closed. We will neither understand nor experience these things.
The first things are cutting off our own will, obedience, and humility. Then, little by little, we begin to taste the Holy Spirit, and only then do we understand what the Holy Fathers wrote and what they intended.
Is this a matter of of personal searching, or does it also concern pastoral ministry – yours and that of other priests?
Of course, the spiritual father, the priest, must guide people. He is a mystagogue. He must lead people into the mysteries of Christ, into the life of the Church. That is his task.
Who brings people into the Church – Christ, the priest, or both together?
Is there any separation between the Church and Christ in pastoral ministry?
No.
Of course, the Church is Christ. That is beyond dispute. But that is not what I mean. I mean bringing someone into the Church, helping them become part of its life and participate in the sacraments of the Orthodox Church. Surely that involves both, including the priest’s pastoral ministry?
Yes, but the priest’s task is not to drag someone into the Church at any cost by lowering the standards and making everything easier. Because in doing so, he is more likely to push that person out than bring him in. There must be no pressure, but neither should there be any cutting and tailoring of Tradition or making life in Christ easier. That is spiritual delusion. The priest must speak the truth, as Christ does. He represents Christ and must convey Christ’s words to people.
There is this idea that we are the ones who will bring people into the Church. I can barely bring myself in, and I’m supposed to bring others No. I must bring them to Christ. Christ does the work. Christ brings people in, Christ arranges everything, Christ seeks out each person and brings him. My responsibility is to faithfully preserve the deposit of faith. Then the door remains open. If I fail to preserve that deposit, Tradition, and dogma, I am the one closing the door to people.
You put it well – we must not cut and reshape Tradition to fit each individual. That would mean “a faith tailored to me or to you.” That is a mistake, and I agree with you. But changing or diminishing Tradition is one thing; bringing someone closer step by step is another. There is room for economia here.
Of course there is economia. We would make many accommodations, but never at the expense of the goal, the faith, or the truth. Otherwise, a person may see one thing at the beginning of the journey and something entirely different at the end, and say, “But that’s not what you told me.”
There is also a particular spiritual delusion among clergy: believing you possess authority you do not actually have and trying to do things that are not yours to do. For example, thinking that I must attract people through human methods. No. I must get out of the way so that people encounter Christ, not my inventions.
The one Church and ecumenism
Is the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church identical to the Orthodox Church?
Absolutely. There is only one. Christ is one: “One Lord, one faith, one baptism.” There is no other.
There are not two Churches, and there never will be.
Identical in the fullest sense – completely the same?
That is our identity. It is not as though there is another “you” somewhere, as though you were divided in two. You are one and the same.
The Church and Christ are inseparable – “yesterday, today, and forever.” Anyone who speaks of a divided Church is spiritually deluded. Anyone who claims that the Church has been divided or can be divided does not know what he is saying. He does not know Christ.
Let me be clear: this is a matter of faith. We say, “I believe in the Church,” and we confess this three times a day – at the Liturgy, at Compline. Every day, a Christian says, “I believe in one God... in one Holy... Church.” We do not merely say that the Church “exists.” We believe in the Church because she is the divine-human Body.
Can Christ be divided, broken into pieces? No.
And yet, through our behavior, we seem to do precisely that.
That is something different. We leave the Church when we follow our passions. But here we are discussing our Creed and what we understand the Church to be.
One in essence and undivided. Now I would like you to explain the word “ecumenism” and identify what you see as its greatest danger to Orthodoxy. Let me repeat the question because it has two parts: I want your personal understanding, not simply a literal definition, and I want to know what you consider the greatest threat ecumenism poses to Orthodoxy.
It is not I who say this. The saints say that ecumenism is a temptation of the last days.
Don’t simply repeat what the saints say. I want to hear your opinion.
My opinion is worth nothing, and I am not going to tell you “how I understand it.” What matters is what the saints say. But let me explain. There is the ecumenical movement. I wrote a book about it, also available in Greek, called The Missionary Origins of Modern Ecumenism. It is a short book.
The movement emerged among Protestants in missionary circles around 1880. Protestants needed to unite among themselves. Its goal was never to return to the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church. It was always about practical objectives – making missionary work more successful. That was the situation then, and it has not changed to this day. Essentially, these were worldly calculations, ideas, and aspirations among Protestants.
And we entered that movement, accepted its framework, and have not changed anything since. We think we have accomplished something, but in practice I see no improvement.
Then, in 1965, the Roman Catholics entered the movement, and the ecclesiology of the Second Vatican Council shaped everything that followed. Many Orthodox Christians have been influenced by the theology of Vatican II, which essentially represents a new understanding of the Church.
So ecumenism is both a movement and a particular understanding of the Church.
In terms of its understanding of what the Church is, ecumenism is a heresy. It speaks of a divided Church, a Church that contains heresy within itself, a Church made up of different parts. These ideas extend even to the sacraments. Some claim that sacraments exist outside the Church. But there can be no sacraments outside the Church. All the sacraments and the very mystery of the Church are one. They cannot be separated.
All these theories about God belong entirely to our age. They are not patristic thought. They do not come from the Fathers. People take fragments from the Fathers to construct an attractive theory, all for the sake of this world and some notion of success. These theories, this prevailing conception of the Church, constitute the greatest temptation of the last days. Because they attack the divine-human Person of Christ.
And that is precisely the temptation Christians will face in the last days: they will lose their faith at the ecclesiological level. They will no longer believe that the Church exists in the world. Instead, they will believe that she has broken into pieces, as many already do. And if there is no Church, there is no salvation. That would mean Christ is not “the same yesterday, today, and forever,” and that we must “build” a new Church.
That is the goal.
Do you believe this is ultimately where things are heading?
I think that, in the coming days, people in the churches will increasingly embrace theories associated with so-called perennialism.
This is an idea we have heard for years from Pope Francis and others – that religions save, that all religions are paths leading to Christ and salvation. Its roots go back 100 to 150 years, to figures such as Frithjof Schuon, René Guénon, and others who believed that religions are outwardly divided but inwardly united, and that all religions are different revelations of the same God.
That is where ecumenism is heading. And that will be the “religion of the future” that Fr. Seraphim Rose spoke about – the religion of the Antichrist.
So they alone perceive this outward division and inward unity, while we do not?
That is exactly what they say. If you are sufficiently “enlightened,” you can perceive this inner unity. These intellectuals embrace such ideas largely through the power of reason alone. Schuon and others like him possessed remarkable intellectual abilities.
They observe similarities: Buddhism teaches this, Christ teaches that, and in certain respects they overlap. From this, they conclude that all religions lead to the same destination.
So one must be an intellectual, have a degree, and be educated? Does that mean God reveals Himself only to those with diplomas?
You took the words right out of my mouth. It is exactly the opposite. The Church praises the fishermen, not the intellectuals.
Heresy, heretics, and heresiarchs
Father, what is heresy? Let me explain why I ask. We laypeople, with our very simplistic reasoning, write about theological matters every day while knowing almost nothing about God. We lecture others, appoint ourselves teachers, and refuse to accept objections: “I am right.” Someone else writes something different on the same subject and is equally convinced that he is right. Yet all of us who are willing to read even two minutes more than others eventually face the same question: What is heresy? Who is a heretic? And, above all, who is a heresiarch?
Heresy is when someone takes a part of the whole and presents it as the whole, or interprets it differently from how the Holy Fathers received it. It is introducing something new or distorting what we have received from the Fathers and making it a point of division, so that people separate over it. That is no longer catholic, conciliar, and apostolic teaching. It is merely a fragment of it.
A fragment?
Yes. And ultimately, it does not matter whether we are speaking about the Person of Christ, the Holy Trinity, or the Church. If a teaching departs from the deposit of faith we have received, it is heresy. And that deposit of faith is necessarily the fruit of experience. We did not invent it. We did not simply decide that it would be a good idea to speak about God in a particular way. Heretics, however, arrive at a new theological position through reasoning and then begin imposing it.
That is what happened, for example, with the Filioque. It did not originate in the conciliar Church but among a small group, and only gradually was it accepted throughout the West
As St. John Climacus says, what heretics have in common is pride. Pride combined with excessive reliance on reasoning.
Forgive me for interrupting again, but pride and egoism also involve the idea of making a “discovery.” Someone takes a fragment, interprets it however he likes, usually distorts it, and then declares, “Look what I’ve discovered.”
Yes. Usually, worldly calculations lie behind this – iconoclasm, for example, and, I believe, ecumenism today.
Incidentally, today we commemorate the Seventh Ecumenical Council.
Yes, today we commemorate the Ecumenical Council that restored the veneration of icons. And let us remember that several years before the Seventh Ecumenical Council, there was a heretical council at which some 350 bishops – 338 bishops at the Council of Hieria in 754 – approved what the emperor wanted: iconoclasm. So secular power and politics are often behind heresy. The same thing happens today.
Quite often, because of politicians and worldly calculations, we introduce new theories about the Church and other matters.
The canceled lecture on Elder Ephraim
If we begin discussing that, Father... And I know you still have a lecture to give after our broadcast.
I have no lecture.
What do you mean?
There was supposed to be a lecture today, Sunday, at St. Demetrios Church as part of the celebrations honoring St. Demetrios. But unfortunately, certain people, for reasons of their own, do not want to hear about Elder Ephraim.
Forgive me, but I have to ask. I am here as a journalist, and you yourself do something similar. Our interview was scheduled, and here we are. Your lecture was scheduled, and now there is no lecture. You are putting me in a difficult position rather than answering my questions. What happened?
The lecture was canceled by order of the Patriarchate. I do not know why.
How do you know that?
The organizers informed us. Unfortunately, at the very last moment – three hours before the lecture – they told us that it could not take place because the Patriarchate did not want it to happen.
Glory to God for all things. Apparently, something changed. I don’t know what.
“Glory to God for all things” – beautifully and rightly said. Was there a change in the program? Am I correct that no reason was given?
No reason was given. They simply said the lecture could not take place. But whoever made that decision might at least have shown some consideration for the fact that someone had flown halfway around the world and that people were planning to come and hear about Elder Ephraim.
What were you planning to speak about today?
About Elder Ephraim, particularly his work within the Patriarchate, in the Archdiocese of America. The lecture would have shown the greatness of the Church, the elder’s character, and the fruits of his labors.
Who does not want people to hear that, and why? That is a question I cannot answer. I don’t know.
Let me ask something else. How were you notified – by phone or by message?
One phone call.
Can you tell us anything more?
All I know is that the lecture was canceled. “Thank you very much for coming all the way from the other side of the world, but the lecture will not take place.” I don’t know. They won’t tell us. It would be good if they explained why they do not want people to hear about the elder. I don’t think that is really the issue. Apparently, something else is behind it. But no explanation has been given. God knows.
Now, where were we? We were talking about heresy.
About what heresy is, who a heretic is, and who a heresiarch is. We had reached the subject of heretics.
Heretics are often driven by worldly calculations and power – the desire to remain in power. They lack the experience of the saints. They do not crucify themselves as the saints do. They do not remain constantly on the cross, in the sense of serving the Church above the world. That is the pattern we see among heretics.
First, they depart from the path, from the ethos, and then they introduce innovations into dogma. That is usually how it happens. Sometimes they depart from dogma first and then fall in their way of life, but usually it is the other way around. In both cases, there is pride, egoism, and self-interest. We must guard against these things.
You have defined a heretic. But what about a heresiarch? What does that term mean ecclesiologically – according to the writings of the Holy Fathers, your studies, and your own understanding?
Well-known heresiarchs include Arius, the pope... These truly represent some of the gravest and worst cases in history. And again, they are usually motivated by their own interests – recognition, power, glory, or making a name for themselves. They stubbornly cling to some false teaching and lead others astray.
In other words, they are people of the devil, not of the Crucified One – not of that profound humility toward which we should at least be striving.
Inter-Christian dialogues and joint prayers
There are many dialogues taking place today, both among Orthodox Churches and between different Christian confessions. Do you see any positive or at least meaningful results from them?
I think even the ecumenists promoting these dialogues today have realized that they are accomplishing nothing. There is something worth mentioning here – something I would have discussed in today's lecture as well.
Five or ten years ago, our parishes in America might have had five catechumens each. Today, they have 50. Sometimes 100 or 150. There is a parish near me with 150 catechumens.
Why is this happening?
Precisely because today, more than ever before in American history, Orthodoxy is being presented properly – online, in parishes, and in society – without compromises or diplomacy, as it should be, with the courage of confession.
People searching for the truth come and find it. They need nothing else. They want the truth because the truth frees them from everything else and gives them peace.
This has nothing to do with ecumenism.
What more evidence do we need to understand that ecumenism amounts to nothing for the Church? At best, it is a waste of time. At worst, it is a path toward the Antichrist. Ecumenism has no future. It might be useful to someone who eventually wants to leave the Church and become a Roman Catholic. Otherwise, people are fleeing heterodoxy and becoming Orthodox.
The solution is missionary work. I have said this many times and written about it in my books: the antidote to ecumenism is mission. The two cannot coexist or work together. Authentic Orthodoxy cannot go hand in hand with ecumenism. They are opposites.
One more question. What is your personal opinion of praying together with non-Orthodox Christians?
Again, my opinion means nothing. What matters is what the Fathers say. We even published a book by Fr. Anastasios Gotsopoulos on the sacred canons – what the Holy Fathers and the canons say about praying together. But don't listen to Fr. Anastasios or to me. Listen to St. Paisios.
His life tells of two Roman Catholics who came to him and wanted to recite the Lord's Prayer together. He told them, "I cannot pray together with you. We do not share the same faith." The prerequisite for prayer is faith – a common faith. And out of genuine love, not false, worldly love, St. Paisios told them they could not pray together. He did this precisely so they would feel something, so that they would experience the "good uneasiness" St. Paisios spoke about. That is what we must give people – good uneasiness.
Ecumenism offers the opposite: a false sense of peace, as though we were already united. That is the worst thing. It is not love. We do not love others when we give them the impression that we are already one.
That is worldly. It is demonic, not of God.
But can we pray for non-Orthodox Christians?
Absolutely. Constantly, with prostrations and, if we can, with tears. Of course we must pray for them – but not with them.
And for sinners – those whom we consider sinners.
That is precisely what all the examples of the saints and of Christ teach us.
The Orthodox ethos
Your website is called Orthodox Ethos. You chose the Greek word "ethos," meaning character or way of life.
Yes, and that is very important. It is the most difficult thing...
Go ahead, and then I'll ask my question.
I chose that word because we speak about Orthodoxy and Orthodox practice, but the most important thing is acquiring the ethos. That is the difficulty for a Western person, a convert, an American. To acquire an ethos, you need examples. You need someone to imitate. When you see a saint – how he sits, how he speaks, how he stands...
That is how I encountered Elder Ephraim 32 years ago. I didn't know Greek at the time, but I saw him, and that was enough. Within seconds, I understood what a saint was and what the purpose of my life was.
Simply by seeing him?
Yes. The way he looked at me, spoke, sat, and walked showed that the Holy Spirit dwelt within him, that his entire body and every movement were filled with the Spirit. It was a lesson in life, and no words were necessary.
That is the Orthodox ethos. It is holiness. It means acquiring a particular way of life. Christ is not only the Truth but also the way of life. This must be emphasized: if we live that kind of life, we will not go astray in dogma either. That is what we need to acquire.
But it is difficult because we lack examples. We cannot manage it. If you remain at the level of rationalism, of the idea of Orthodoxy, of merely professing it, you have no experience of Orthodoxy. You do not move forward or change. You do not acquire self-knowledge, you do not see yourself, and you cannot progress spiritually. Even if you know the canons and all of Church history perfectly, it makes no difference.
Rationalism and faith
It seems to me that rationalism doesn't really help with any of this. For the benefit of our viewers, perhaps we should say that a faith like our Orthodox faith cannot be lived through unrestrained rationalism. We need to understand things through experience and through the soul as well. What the mind grasps must also be felt, at least to some degree. When you saw Elder Ephraim, you didn't say, "He is a saint because I saw him," but rather, "He is a saint because I felt it."
Yes. You don't stop at rationalism. That is what faith is. We live by faith. And faith is not merely about something that will happen in the future. Faith is trust, a direct relationship with God. We live by trusting Christ, and that transcends reason.
Indeed, the entire Gospel proclaims the transcendence of nature. From the Incarnation to the last mystery of the Church, we encounter something beyond the natural order. Holy Communion cannot be contained within the limits of logic or nature, within the ordinary nature of things. It transcends them.
Our entire life should be lived in this state – living by faith. It is not simply believing something like, "God is good, and He will take care of us in the future." Right now, directly, I have a relationship with Him. I live and walk within that relationship – within God's providence and His will. I seek His will above everything else.
What strikes me about Elder Ephraim's life is that, like St. Joseph the Hesychast, he wanted to fulfill God's will in everything. He would not take a single step unless he was certain it was God's will. They could wait a very long time before making a decision if there was no sign or indication that this was what God wanted. That is how we should try to live, as much as we can.
Reason alone will not help us here. We will make mistakes.
A few days ago, sitting in the very chair you're sitting in now, was Konstantinos Fountas, a physicist who works at CERN. Our conversation turned to Holy Communion and the coronavirus. He challenged those who were saying, "Receive Communion – you won't catch anything." We discussed it for about five minutes, with a certain tension – a healthy scientific tension on his part, since I'm not a scientist. Eventually, we came to holy water. I told him, "If we disagree about Communion, let's at least consider holy water." I suggested an experiment: take two bottles of water from a kiosk. Fr. Peter blesses one and leaves the other unblessed. Then we put them somewhere for two years. After two years, all sorts of things will have grown in one bottle, while the other will remain clean. He laughed, but he didn't say no.
He lacks the experience. You see?
That is precisely where rationalism comes in. You used a very accurate and wise word. I'm not trying to lecture anyone, but I experienced this on Mount Athos with the late Fr. Nissimos, who lived opposite Koutloumousiou Monastery. We talked a great deal about rationalism. It is disastrous for those who lack knowledge. I include myself first: when I don't know something, I try to reason my way through it. But that doesn't work.
Exactly as you say. He lacked the experience, and that is why he reached that conclusion. But God shows us that prayer changes everything. The life of the Church demonstrates this.
I remember a miracle in Chicago 30 years ago. An icon of the Mother of God was streaming myrrh – even from the eyes. It was extraordinary. We all went there. Bishop Basil, whom I mentioned earlier and who has been so important in my life, was there.
A journalist asked him, "How do you explain this miracle?" And the bishop replied, "But we have miracles every week, every day in the Church. Holy Communion is a miracle. This doesn't surprise us. It is the life of the Church."
If you do not live within the Church, you cannot transcend logic and escape rationalism. You remain confined within those limits. You are not truly living. In a sense, you are living in a cage. You are not free. But the Church gives birth to free people because they live beyond the limits of reason.
And to finish the story about Mr. Fountas, at the end he even apologized jokingly: "Forgive me for not saying what you wanted to hear." I replied, "You said exactly what you needed to say. We don't need people who agree with everything." He is an excellent scientist, with a wonderful sense of humor and a sharp wit. He gave us a very good interview and made an excellent impression.
Love and criticism
The Orthodox ethos. We can agree that love is part of that ethos – perhaps even its foundation.
Of course, but it must be the love of Christ, not merely human love. We live – Christ lives within us – and we love in Christ.
This is not human love. It is the grace of God dwelling within us, and it is through that grace that believers are united. In it, we are one.
"If I have not love, I am nothing," as the Apostle Paul says in his Epistle to the Corinthians.
I remember something an Athonite monk told me recently. I liked it very much. He had met Elder Ephraim many times, and after each meeting he would weep and wonder what it was that the elder possessed – what it is that dwells within a holy person, within every saint. Eventually, he understood: it was the love of Christ living within him. Later, he came across an old talk by the elder in which Elder Ephraim recalled praying when he first arrived in America: "My Christ, I will not be able to labor here for You unless You give me Your love, so that I can give it to the people." We are not talking about worldly love – emotional, human love, which is often selfish. That has nothing in common with the sacrificial, crucified love of Christ, which changes everything.
From our conversation, I gather that you pray for those whom you criticize. Do you do so before criticizing them or afterward?
We must pray constantly – both before and afterward. Unfortunately, we are human. Often, what we say is rationally correct, but we say it without love, and therefore it does not produce the same results. We try to do everything with love so that it bears fruit.
St. Paisios speaks beautifully about this as well. You can strike someone with the truth instead of setting him free with it. That happens when we speak without love. The spiritual struggle of a believer is to do everything with love.
Truth and love must never be separated. It is difficult because today there are so many challenges. We constantly have to address problems and sensitive issues, and discernment is needed to know when to speak and when to remain silent.
Dialogue with opponents
Do you think meeting someone who has long disagreed with you, or whom you have criticized, could be beneficial?
I would very much like that. I would really like to speak and meet with those who criticize me or disagree with me.
So dialogue should continue even when it doesn't produce the desired result?
Look, not every dialogue. Sometimes people engage in dialogue simply for the sake of dialogue. Elder Athanasios Mytilinaios says – I even gave a talk based on his words – that there is dialogue from God and dialogue from the devil.
We need discernment. Not every dialogue is good, and we do not engage in dialogue merely for its own sake. For example, Eve's dialogue with the serpent was evil. That was the beginning of coexistence with evil.
That's a very good observation. There was no shared problem there – there was deception. But here we do have a shared problem.
If there is a willingness to learn... People approached Christ with different dispositions. Some came as disciples, seeking clarification and deeper understanding: "Lord, explain this to us." That is how the disciples approached Him. And that is blessed because they came to Christ with humility and wanted to learn. I am not speaking about myself but about Christ. Everyone approaches Christ through someone, but it is Christ they are seeking. What matters is the disposition with which they come. If the disposition is good, dialogue bears fruit, as we see with the Apostles. The Pharisees and others also came and engaged Christ in dialogue. But the outcome was disastrous because they lacked humility and a willingness to submit.
That is the problem with ecumenism. When dialogue between Roman Catholics and Orthodox Christians began in 1965, it was defined, if I remember correctly, by the Greek expression epi isois horois – "on equal terms." In other words, both sides were placed on the same level.
That is a mistake. You cannot have dialogue with heresy on equal terms, as though Orthodoxy and heresy stood on the same level. Such dialogue will bear no fruit.
But if non-Orthodox Christians come to Christ – and the Church is Christ – if they come to the Church wanting to understand, learn, and submit to her, that is blessed, and much good will come of it.
Ecumenical dialogue, however, is not built on that foundation.
I'd like to stay with the subject of dialogue a little longer, but not ecumenical dialogue. Suppose you and I disagree and argue on social media. You write one thing, I write another, you respond, and I respond in turn. Meanwhile, the people reading our exchanges are already being hurt by the dispute. Then, at some point, we agree to meet in person and end our "war" on social media. Which of us would approach the other as a disciple?
A true disciple of Christ is always a disciple. Yes, he may speak the words of Christ and the Holy Fathers, but he regards himself as a disciple. Therefore, it is not difficult for him to approach Christ together with another person, as a disciple.
All right, let me put it differently. Who will be the first to write or call the other and say, "Let's talk"?
It's a specific question, and it's a question of ego. It may be a question of ego, but it may also be a question of discernment. The two are not always the same. Continuing a dialogue can itself be unwise. Remember the example of Patriarch Jeremiah and the Lutheran Protestants?
Tell us about that example.
They corresponded for years, back in the 16th century – the exchange between Patriarch Jeremiah II and the theologians of Tübingen, from 1573 to 1581. At a certain point, the patriarch said, "Enough. This dialogue serves no purpose." And he ended it. So it is not always necessary to keep up a dialogue for its own sake, talking and talking endlessly. Sometimes it is better to stop and allow the other person to think, struggle, and wrestle with the question.
God, of course, never stops speaking to a person. But it is not always beneficial for us to speak with everyone about everything.
What is difficult for you personally? Think of someone – you don't have to give a name, position, or ecclesiastical rank – with whom it would be worthwhile to speak, but whom you don't want to approach. In other words, you understand that a conversation might be beneficial, but you hesitate because your disagreements are so profound.
I won't name anyone.
You can say whatever you like. I'm not pressuring you. Any name, any rank.
I would very much like to speak with those Church hierarchs who believe that because we occasionally criticize certain decisions and documents, we somehow hate, for example, the institution of the Patriarchate. That's what I would say.
Is the Patriarch an Orthodox bishop?
What does "Orthodox" mean? Someone who thinks rightly and "rightly divides the word of truth," or someone who is Orthodox by title? He certainly occupies the episcopal see.
The question is straightforward: is he an Orthodox bishop?
If that means he rightly divides the word of truth, then in my view, no – not entirely. He makes mistakes in ecclesiology.
Let's move to the second question. We pray for those who make mistakes, too.
Of course we do.
So you would speak with him, and that would be beneficial?
God grant it. I'm nobody, just a simple priest from Thessaloniki. The Patriarch doesn't have time to speak with me.
Don't frame it that way. Suppose he wanted to speak with you.
Of course, we would be glad to have a conversation.
Is he Orthodox? By virtue of his position, certainly. He is the Patriarch of Constantinople. But does he "rightly divide the word of truth"? No. And it is not for me to decide the matter. This is a conciliar question, a matter for the Local Churches. The entire conciliar system must correct any bishop, wherever he may be, if he does not rightly divide the word of truth. That is the responsibility of the Church.
Let me change the question. Fr. Peter is walking through Texas and encounters the Patriarch, or anyone else with whom he has, let's say, purely human disagreements. After all, those disagreements don't come from God.
Yes, I believe that.
Would you speak to him? Would he speak to you?
Of course.
Good. Next question. So you pray for those whom you subject to theological criticism – specifically theological criticism.
Yes, it is not personal.
That is why I emphasize theological criticism. And the other side should have the right to respond. Ever since I was told at the Union of Orthodox Journalists that I would be interviewing you, I have been reading your work. What I pay the most attention to is how you write and speak. For me, that is the alpha and omega. You identify a problem, but you also propose a solution. You don't simply point to it and shout about it. That is what matters most to me. Without a proposed solution, all that remains is the problem itself. And you offer solutions grounded in the Holy Fathers and the Councils.
That is how it should be. What is the point of discussing problems if we are not looking for solutions, if we are not directing people toward healing? The Church is a hospital. We heal. We want healing. That is what matters most.
On the program I used to host, we often received 70, 80, or 100 questions in a single evening. We would broadcast for three hours on Tuesdays and Thursdays. I do it less frequently now because I don't have the time, but I used to host it twice a week. People have so many questions. They are thirsty for the truth.
The Church must give people answers. There may be a thousand questions, but the central question is always the same: How can I be saved?
Exactly. That is what matters most, at least to me as a journalist and as a person, setting my profession aside. There is no point if my spiritual father simply tells me, "You made a mistake," or "You must do this." If he doesn't show me the solution, I have a serious problem. But when I tell him everything, he does offer a solution. Sometimes we must find the solution ourselves, but even then, he helps show us the way.
Yes, he shows us the path.
The Ukrainian issue: the root lies in ecclesiology
We now face a problem known as the "Ukrainian issue."
Look, I would say that our problem is always fundamentally the same, including here: Christ. What I mean is that we must choose whether to follow Christ or follow the world. That is where all divisions and problems begin.
Our task is to discern, understand, and acquire self-knowledge – to recognize when we have departed from Christ's path and repent.
So someone must repent for what happened in Ukraine. Who has enough humility to do that?
They say some people already understand that they made a mistake. Now they need the courage and faith to say, "Forgive us."
That brings us back to the question of meeting. Who will make the first call or send the first message?
The one who has more of Christ within him. Christ is also present in the other person, but to a lesser degree. The difficulty is that renouncing one's own will and acknowledging a mistake here would have enormous consequences.
This is not merely a personal decision, and the consequences would not be merely personal. The person who made the mistake must crucify himself. But if he crucifies himself, he will be exalted, and therein lies his salvation.
May God grant him the courage to do so – for his own salvation and for the good of the Church, for the sake of the very ecclesiastical institution in whose name, they claim, everything was done.
Do you think bishops – including those in higher positions, all the way up to patriarchs – have spiritual fathers?
Bishops? Yes, they do.
Surely they must have someone. I know you weren't expecting this question, but I want to ask it.
How would I know whether they have a genuine spiritual father? If they don't, woe to them. May God help them. A spiritual father is the most important thing in the Church, especially for a priest or bishop. If you have no spiritual father, you are blind. Do you know what the Fathers say? He who is his own spiritual father has a fool for a spiritual father.
Lord, have mercy. How, in your opinion, can someone come to his senses and acknowledge a mistake – I'm speaking about bishops – if we assume that someone, as you suggested without naming names, bears responsibility for the Ukrainian issue?
I would put it this way: perhaps both sides bear responsibility, but at different levels and in different respects. I am speaking primarily about ecclesiology. That is where the problem lies. Behind our entire problem is ecclesiology.
Please explain.
It is the same issue in both ecumenism and the Ukrainian question: the identity of the Church and the way the Church operates. There is a major crisis here. We have departed from the Orthodox way of doing things.
For example – without naming names or particular situations – both in the Ukrainian question and elsewhere, when a bishop says, "I don't bear responsibility. I don't want responsibility. Let the Patriarch take responsibility and make this decision," even when the matter is extremely important, and he does not want the conciliar system to function, then forgive me, but that bishop has a problem. His way of thinking is not Orthodox.
What does it mean to say, "Let the Patriarch decide for the entire Church"? That is papism, not Orthodox ecclesiology. We see this in our Church. A kind of neo-papism has emerged in many Local Churches, and the bishops themselves now want it.
That is a mystery to me. Do you want this because you don't want to bear responsibility? Or do they have other problems? I don't know. Or perhaps their understanding of the Church has become deeply distorted. Decisions affecting the entire Orthodox world, the entire Church, cannot be made by one person, even a patriarch. That is not Orthodox.
In the Acts of the Apostles, it does not say, "Peter has decided." It says, "It seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us." To the Holy Spirit and to us – not to me. I believe this is the root of the problem, both in the Ukrainian question and in ecumenism, and in all the issues where divisions arise at this level. We are not following Orthodoxy itself. We are not following the Holy Fathers. That is where the whole problem begins.
Why did the pope fall away, along with everything that followed? Because they did not follow the Holy Fathers. They departed from them. They did not consider it important to follow the Fathers precisely and faithfully, and before long they had gone very far astray. We, too, have gone far astray, yet we do not repent or return to the foundations. Of course, many factors are involved, including political ones. But that is the fundamental problem in the Ukrainian issue.
Now imagine you're at home in Texas. The phone rings, and someone says, "Get on a plane and fly to France," for example. At a table, on one side, sits the Ukrainian side – I don't like dividing the Church into sides, but I don't know how else to put it – and on the other, the Ecumenical Patriarch. They tell you, "Take a pen and paper and write down five solutions for us, no more." Would you turn over the sheet and say, "Listen, here is what I propose: this, this, and this"? Would you agree to serve as a mediator to help resolve this enormous problem?
Of course. Everyone must be willing to make concessions, but on the foundation of Orthodox ecclesiology. That is nonnegotiable.
Would you do it?
The solution is simple.
How so? In theory, renouncing one's own will, and everything else falls into place?
Yes. We must be prepared to sacrifice secondary things – worldly concerns and interests. If we cannot do that, we are not Christians. If I insist on secondary and tertiary matters and place them above Christ and unity in Christ, then of course the problem will continue. So resolving it is not difficult. The difficulty is humbling ourselves.
In other words, sacrificing our ego and worldly interests, as you were saying.
Yes. But we must also follow the Holy Fathers. It is not enough to speak humbly and say, "I'm a bad person. Bless me." We must then correct the systemic problems that arise when we depart from patristic thought and patristic ecclesiology.
So there is a broader departure from these principles today.
Yes, there is.
Perhaps that is why this situation developed.
Everyone knows it.
Well, I'm not the last person to know – I don't know. That's why I'm asking you.
Everyone knows, but nobody says anything. That is the problem today. Everyone skirts around the issue, and nobody comes out and says, "Here it is."
Why does that happen? Because we're thinking about ourselves? Look, in one case it may be discernment; in another, cowardice. It is not always one or the other. Sometimes it is worldliness: "I don't want to lose anything." In other cases, it is genuine discernment. We must examine each context and each situation individually. The zealots lack that discernment. To them, everyone is a coward and everyone is worldly. But that is not always true.
Elder Ephraim, for example, possessed extraordinary discernment.
On Elder Ephraim
Please say a few words about Elder Ephraim. Since, as you told us, you won't be able to speak about him today where you were supposed to, tell us here about St. Ephraim.
About the elder – forgive me for calling him a saint, but that is how I regard him. Through the elder, God saved the Church in America. Fifty or sixty years ago, Fr. John Romanides wrote that unless an Athonite monk came and began establishing monasteries, the Church in America would perish because secularization and Protestantization had reached such extremes.
And the elder came, with tremendous love and patience. Thousands of souls came to confession and repentance. His work was extraordinary. Nothing like it had happened in Church history: 17 monasteries in America, eight in Greece, thousands of souls, and hundreds of monks and nuns.
But it is not so much about the numbers as about the quality of Christ's love for every person who stood before him. You could feel it. When you entered his room for confession, you felt that, at that moment, you were the most important person in the world to the elder. That was the kind of love he had. And he transformed thousands of souls simply by bringing them into contact with such love.
He possessed extraordinary discernment. It was the fruit of his experience, but also of his love: knowing when to speak, when to insist, and when to remain silent. He never responded to the criticism directed at him. Never. That is remarkable. He was subjected to terrible criticism. People lied about him and said unbelievable things.
Some even tried to kill him.
Kill him?
Yes, twice. You'll read about it in his biography. He endured a great deal.
What do you mean, they tried to kill him?
Yes, there were two attempts on his life. You'll see it in the biography, which comes out the day after tomorrow. I haven't read the entire book, only excerpts, but he is a great saint. We still haven't understood him.
St. Porphyrios used to say, "Elder Ephraim conceals it" – meaning his holiness.
And now, in due time, that holiness will be revealed and will help even more people. He continues to act even after his repose: he appears to people, speaks, guides, helps, and prays. He is a great saint of the Church.
Glory to God. Your website's logo features a saint or an elder in a cave, if I remember correctly. Who is it?
It is not a particular person. The figure represents the Orthodox ethos: prayer, contrition, and the heart's love for the world.
Does Fr. Peter, who presumably came up with that logo or played a major role in creating it, follow the example he presents to others? I mean the life of concentration and solitude. Do you live according to the example you hold up to people?
You're a very good interviewer. [Laughter.] Ask my wife. She would probably say no. [Laughter.] Probably not. I make mistakes often. All of that will be revealed in the end. We won't see it ourselves, but we hope others will intercede for us, both from below and from above.
But here's the thing: whatever happens, I try to speak the truth – what the Holy Fathers teach. Even if I do not have that experience myself, woe to me if I begin saying something different and contradicting the saints and elders.
Essentially, I am still a catechumen. I am still learning what Orthodoxy is, and I will continue learning until the end. I am trying to understand it through experience. The lives of the saints, the life of Elder Ephraim, are so far removed from the Orthodoxy most people live today. I cannot explain exactly why or in what way, but I feel it and sometimes see it in particular moments and examples. I realize that the mystery of holiness the elder experienced has little in common with much of what we say about Orthodoxy.
Everything we do and say remains at the level of human reasoning and arguments. But the elder had gone far beyond that. He was already living eternal life here on earth. So what can I say? Do I live according to what I teach? No. I merely point the way: there, go there.
Anger and attachment to material things
Let's bring the conversation a little closer to our viewers' everyday lives. We all get angry every day, from morning until night. Even now, I seem calm, but I'm still a little irritated: I wrote down one set of questions, and we're discussing something else entirely. I won't ask about the pastoral ministry of priests. Instead, tell people what they should strive for when they have an example to follow. How should someone deal with anxiety and worry? I know the question is subjective, but I'll accept a general answer. We get irritated every day, often for no reason. I get angry with you, you get angry with someone else. We feel we're missing something. We constantly want something because someone else has it and we don't. What is this state we're in?
First, if we are attached to material things, we will become angry. So we need to put things in their proper order and understand what has value and what does not, at least intellectually. If we can step back a little and look at ourselves more objectively, recognize our own wretchedness, and ask God, "Enlighten my mind so that I may see my own wretchedness," then we can begin to overcome anger. We must keep our own wretchedness before our eyes rather than focusing on what someone else is doing. Always keep your own shortcomings in view. Then we will be able to cut off some of our anger because we will no longer be so attached to things that are not worth it.
And there is another aspect: understanding what we are losing. We don't realize what we are losing. We cannot hate sin because we enjoy it. It gives us temporary, false consolation. But we do not understand what it costs us. We need to pray, "My God, show me what I will lose through this sin, through this way of life." And when you compare the two – what you stand to lose and what you are gaining in return – you begin to say, "It's not worth it." Anger is not worth it. It is nothing compared with eternity and life in Christ.
So we need to step back and look at life differently, moving from a very narrow perspective to a broader one. Rise a thousand meters above everything and look at it as God sees it. Take a wider view, recognize the limits of your own perspective, and understand how insignificant these things are. They are not worth it.
Yet we remain stuck in them every day, thinking we can accomplish something through force, pressure, and insistence.
Children and music
Children and music are a huge subject for me personally. I produced 44 radio programs for one station, inviting well-known experts, and I always raised the subject of music. Here in Greece, we went through a long period – four or five years – when trap music dominated. It was a huge problem. We invited psychiatrists, priests, academics, and ordinary people like myself, and we discussed it extensively.
My question is this: we know that music influences children and adults. What should we as parents do to guide our children toward the right kind of music? I was born in 1974. I grew up with heavy metal, rock, and the Greek music of that era. Fortunately, it didn't do me any harm. Or did it?
Do you think it shows? [Laughter.]
You tell me.
No, I don't think it did you any great harm in that sense. But when we give our soul, our life, and our heart to something that is not Christ, something that is not eternal and has no eternal significance, we lose something. There are degrees to this, an entire spectrum. In your case, perhaps it was something minor. You lost a little.
I also grew up outside the Church, and at one time I really enjoyed that kind of music. I wouldn't say it harmed me greatly or led me astray. After all, I eventually came to Orthodoxy. But the time I spent on it and everything I "gained" from it represent a loss.
All right. But I don't think we always do things because we expect to gain something. In my day, music was simply a way to relax over a cup of coffee, nothing more. I grew up in a village. Today, however, we face a different problem, although it is gradually fading – trap music, a form of rap. I don't know whether you're familiar with what the lyrics are about.
It's noisy filth, not music.
What should we parents pay attention to in music and clothing – let me broaden the question a little – to protect our children?
All these things weigh so heavily on the soul that they burden it tremendously. So I would say we need to remove children from that environment, even for just 24 hours – a day, two days, three or four – and immerse them in light, peace, and silence. The child needs to discover for himself: this agitates me, I've become attached to it, my soul is clinging to it. Neither the lyrics nor the music itself inspires anything. There is no communion with God or with other people in it. It is something dead. But here, I have rest and peace.
Only through that kind of experience can liberation come. Simply telling children, "Be careful, be careful," won't accomplish anything because they are easily influenced. They want to be with other children, have friends, and so on. But if they experience what it means to be free of those things, they can begin to understand.
It's the same with the internet. If a child is constantly online and then spends a day, two days, or a week in nature, he will experience what it means to live a real life, in contact with nature and other people rather than with a machine. The principle is similar.
So the problem is... Experience is the key, you're saying. We need to take children out of that environment. True, but some parents have had the same kind of "experience" themselves. What should they do? I see these people every day because I spend a great deal of time working with children, and this concerns me deeply. There are people around 30 years old who grew up listening to the wrong music and watching the wrong films, whether in movie theaters or on YouTube. Now their children are growing up with the wrong role models. This is where pastoral ministry comes in, but a person must want to come to the Church himself. You cannot drag him in, as you said at the beginning. That is the problem, because today's child is tomorrow's parent. What kind of society are we going to build?
I don't think declaring war on these things directly will produce results. Children will simply stop telling us about them. They'll hide what they're doing. Christ must shine forth – the light that enters the darkness and draws them out.
In other words, the lives of parents or friends must be brighter, more beautiful, and more attractive, so that children themselves will want to leave those things behind.
There is no other solution. No one abandons sin or darkness through force.
But the child doesn't even know. He's in darkness, like in Plato's cave.
Yes, exactly, the cave. He doesn't understand. He cannot simply get up and leave to see the light. All he sees are the shadows behind him. So shouting, "Get out of there! Stop it! That's bad!" will not help. But if he gains firsthand experience, if he comes to understand, discern, and compare for himself, then he will be able to leave.
Marriage and same-sex unions
“And the two shall become one flesh,” we say of marriage. Now let’s turn to the laws that have been passed in Greece – the 2024 law legalizing same-sex marriage. You know them very well. What happens in a person’s mind when he accepts something as marriage that is not marriage? At least to me, it is not marriage. It is something entirely different, although I cannot put it that way from the position I currently occupy. What happens in someone’s mind if he begins to accept, even slightly, that marriage between two people of the same sex is an expression of freedom and that Christ loves everyone? I am speaking about same-sex marriage. What happens in my mind if I say, “All right, there’s nothing wrong with it. God loves them,” and perhaps even make a statement such as, “These people are children of God too. There’s nothing wrong with it”? The consequences could be even worse. Even more troubling laws could be passed, while people retreat into apathy, saying, “Well, it’s fine.” Would that be even worse?
Yes, yes.
My question is: what could happen if we accept this situation without objection?
What happened after Sodom? How did it all end?
Do you think we will reach that point?
Of course. The holy elders have already said that the consequences of carnal sin – including within marriage, not only outside it – as well as abortion and fornication, will be a third world war, which is approaching. And it could happen very soon.
When we become so indifferent to the truth and even console ourselves with a false, essentially satanic condition, what is God to do? You have made your choice. Spiritual laws are at work. Without repentance, everything will follow its course, as a form of correction. You will reap the consequences of your choice.
You are no longer truly living. You are already spiritually dead, a walking corpse, if you live in such a union and are governed by carnal desire. Understand that this is not life. So what is God to do when the world remains unrepentant and indifferent to its salvation?
Essentially, this reflects a lack of love – on the part of society, its leaders, and our brothers and sisters – toward these people and toward society as a whole. You do not love society, God, or your neighbor if you sit back indifferently and say, “Let everyone do whatever they want.” It is as though someone were running toward a cliff and you said, “Goodbye, have a nice trip.” Is that love? No. That is exactly what you are doing when you see something like this and do nothing, say nothing, or even declare that it is good and that everyone should do as they please.
But the consequences will not fall on one individual alone. They will affect society as a whole. That is what will happen. And beyond that, may God help us.
You said “including within marriage.” Can serious sins also occur within marriage? I’m listening carefully.
That is what the saints say, not I. What can I add? The saints, including St. Porphyrios, speak very forcefully about this. The purpose of marriage is love, but also children. If we depart from those boundaries, then even within marriage we are acting outside God’s will when we engage in things that do not bear those fruits. In other words, love is expressed within the boundaries God has established and in service of life – at the very least, through the spouses’ openness to life. When they cross those boundaries and everything becomes selfish, directed solely toward carnal desire, the purpose of marriage and its blessing are lost. And just as there can be lawlessness and acts contrary to nature outside marriage, so there can be within marriage.
Some people assume that everything that happens within marriage is blessed. That is a mistake. Marriage has its own identity and meaning. It is not a matter of saying, “We can do whatever we want because we have God’s blessing.” That is spiritual delusion. The holy elders say that such unnatural relations lead to something even worse. In fact, they can be worse than similar conduct outside marriage. Because you have received the blessing of marriage. You are living within God’s blessing, yet you fail to honor or respect it. Essentially, you are desecrating that blessing.
Yes, I understand. It is like receiving a blessing and then trampling on it. That is worse than never receiving the blessing at all.
Isn’t that so? It is like receiving Holy Communion and then going off and...
You are married. Marriage is holy. It is a sacrament, and you must respect what you have received. It is a blessing. There are three persons in marriage, not two – you are united in Christ. If you do something that is not blessed, you are acting not only against the other person but also against Christ, who blesses you. I think that is why it is more serious, and why the saints speak about these sins.
Yes. I take everything you have said more as advice than criticism, and people respond better to it that way.
Of course. I do my best... We all begin with desires, and we must learn to cut them off. There is no one who does not have desires. We must learn to restrain them and follow the path of spiritual struggle and chastity.
That is precisely the problem. In modern society, people do not ask to be taught, and we ourselves do not seek instruction. Perhaps – and I do not mean this as a reproach – the pastoral ministry of priests is not always what it should be. Perhaps it needs to be somewhat more active, not coercive, but more tangible, with a more living presence.
Yes. Sometimes people need a word that is clear and even firm, but spoken with love. Not severity without discernment, but firmness accompanied by love.
Exactly. People need that.
The spiritual father and the bishop
Do you hear confessions? Are you a spiritual father?
Yes, although I am unworthy. Young people, adults, children – people come. There are not many of us where we live, but people do come. I do not have thousands, as I did in Greece, but hundreds.
And who guides you in practice?
My spiritual father.
Your bishop is far away in America, given the distances and everything else. Do you have opportunities to communicate here in Greece or at conferences?
Yes. But even in Greece, do not imagine that most bishops are pastors in that sense. They are administrators. That is a problem – seeing the bishop as an administrator rather than...
What do we lose because of that?
A great deal. There is even a notion that a bishop is supposed to be an administrator rather than a pastor and spiritual father.
But his title includes “arch-.” He is a metropolitan, not an administrative employee of the metropolia.
A hierarch. That is the better word. A hierarch – the first among priests.
So what do we lose?
We end up in a family without a father. What do we lose in such a family? A great deal. Take all the problems among Black Americans, for example – everything points to the absence of a father.
Being an Orthodox priest in America
What is it like to be an Orthodox priest in America? More specifically, how do people treat you?
I would say that over the past five years, there has been a major change, both among Orthodox Christians and among people outside the Church. A very positive change. People see us on the subway – even those who are completely unfamiliar with Orthodoxy – and wonder, “Who are you?” They want to know. They sense that there is something about you.
What do you mean by people who are completely unfamiliar?
They do not know what you are. Are you Muslim? Jewish? They have no idea, but they are curious. Then they learn, “You’re Orthodox? Oh, Orthodox! Tell me more!” Especially since COVID, the world has changed. Many people have realized that our problems are spiritual in nature, not political, and that politics cannot solve them. They have lost all hope in politics and now look at a priest differently. Perhaps he has something to tell us.
That has changed, and it is very good for the Church. There are opportunities for missionary work. Even within the Church, people used to take everything for granted.
COVID frightened people a little – in a good way – and they turned toward the Church.
Yes, yes. Even longtime Orthodox Christians who had taken the Church for granted. At least in America, many suddenly said, “Oh, the church is closed. I can’t go to services.” And they began seeking out the Church and appreciating it. Not everyone, but many. And that is good. God allows trials because good can come from them. We often fail to understand that because we see only the negative. But a great deal of good came out of COVID.
And all that spiritual delusion – there was tremendous delusion within the Church. Closing churches, administering Communion with multiple spoons, pressuring people to get vaccinated – all of that was spiritual delusion, a terrible delusion among Orthodox Christians. I have said this from the beginning, and I continue to say it today. I do not care who criticizes me. It was spiritual delusion. It was not Orthodox.
And you do not need to listen to me. Listen to St. Paisios. Elder Euthymios of Kapsala, a disciple of St. Paisios, said shortly after the beginning of COVID that St. Paisios would not have worn a mask, taken the vaccine, or practiced social distancing. He would not have done any of the things we were told to do. Therefore, we acted wrongly when we pressured people to do all those things. We did not follow the saints.
A few months ago, Greece’s Deputy Minister of Health, Marios Themistocleous, sat in this very chair. We had a rather tense ten-minute discussion about the coronavirus. The deputy minister said that vaccines had helped and saved lives. That was his position as a physician, grounded in science and medicine. I told him what my spiritual father had said: “If you get vaccinated, you have my blessing. If you don’t, you also have my blessing. But for now, don’t do it, because there is not yet conclusive evidence that the vaccines are appropriate.” He did not dispute that.
He also said that the Church may have been an ally, since some hierarchs encouraged vaccination. But on the other hand, he thought it was not necessarily a bad thing that the Church had also made people understand – not exactly “don’t do it,” but “listen to the Church as well, to those who are telling you to remain calm.” In other words, the situation had been blown out of proportion. My point to him was that I did not trust what was happening, and my entire family remained unvaccinated – primarily because of the way pressure was being applied to us.
Very rightly so.
He did not argue with that, and we moved on to another subject. He is a man of conviction and a wonderful person, like all our guests. I will send you the interview. It is very good. But returning to the methods used: you receive a fine, or someone tells you, “Don’t go outside,” “Fill out a form,” “Do this,” or “Send a text message to get permission to leave home.” So if I go outside without a form, I will supposedly become infected, but if I pay a 100-euro fine, everything is fine? Do you see what I mean?
That is spiritual delusion. I said so from the very beginning, and to this day I cannot understand certain spiritual figures in the Church – bishops and others – who rushed to get vaccinated and close churches. There is only one question I have never been able to resolve. Were the methods being used deceitful and demonic, or were they not? I immediately produced a program called The Demonic Method of the Coronavirus. Everything that was introduced, right up to vaccination, involved methods that were not of God but of the devil: pressure, threats, lies – all of it. I recognized that immediately, without knowing anything about medicine or law.
And you do not need to know those things to recognize it. Even the simplest woman, if she has a spiritual life, would say, “This is not from God.” How could bishops and priests fail to understand that? How can they still fail to understand it today? That troubles me deeply because this is elementary to the life of the Church. You do not need to know everything. No one can know everything. But you can have an experiential, practical sense that a particular method, a particular ethos, is not from God. That is something all of us can recognize.
Yes, the methods themselves demonstrated that. On the other hand, many churches and metropolias held services secretly and gave people Communion. I am saying this publicly. We all received Communion. Nobody became infected. Nothing happened. The coronavirus existed, it has existed for years, and it will continue to exist. It is a virus. Why it was treated on such an enormous scale is another question. We will not go into that now. God willing, perhaps another time. But the methods themselves clearly indicated that something was wrong.
I am preparing a program on repentance. Because public mistakes and public sins require public repentance.
Exactly.
Things will not go well for us in the future – when the next problem or crisis comes – unless we repent of what we have done. I do not say this out of pride. I am nobody. But these are spiritual laws. If we have not repented, if we have not asked forgiveness for such serious mistakes in the past, we will do even worse in the future.
That is why repentance is necessary. These are spiritual laws. When we repent, those consequences are removed, and we return to the right path. This is no small matter. The entire Church needs discussion, sincerity, self-knowledge, and repentance. Otherwise, things will not go well for us.
The prophetic voice of the Church
We should not blame the Church for everything. As a layman with no ecclesiastical rank, I would suggest that you begin by holding one, two, three, or four conferences – perhaps even a council – on how to speak with politicians. Everything goes through politicians, as you know very well. No decision is made or overturned until a politician says yes or no. I have connections with many of them, and I do not know whether they are prepared to receive instruction in the faith. Even if they accept something, would it be out of fear or personal advantage? This deserves serious examination. It is an enormous subject and should be at the top of the agenda because decisions are made not by ordinary people like us but by politicians. What are you doing for politicians? How will you teach them the faith?
Look, whatever happens, we must set an example. We cannot expect the world to possess the mind of Christ. Do not expect that.
So that politicians can see the example of a priest?
Of course. The Church must set an example in these matters. The Church has a prophetic position in the world, a prophetic voice. She has not only a pastoral ministry but also a prophetic ministry. And the prophetic position is one of freedom. It frees people to walk the narrow path of salvation.
If we abandon all of this for supposedly pastoral reasons – which are often merely excuses because we are cowards, although sometimes there are genuine pastoral reasons...
That is very candid of you – what you said about cowardice.
Notice that in the Book of Revelation, the first sin listed among those leading a person into the fire of Gehenna is cowardice. Being a coward is no small matter. It means you lack faith and trust in God. So let us not hide behind claims that we are acting out of love or discernment. Often that is not the case. We are simply covering up our weaknesses.
The Church must speak to the world with precisely this prophetic voice. That is something we are sorely lacking today. As a result, we keep moving without knowing where we are going.
Father, if you tell a politician or an ordinary person, “Speak prophetically,” or “Prove that the ancient prophecies have been fulfilled,” people will call you an alarmist obsessed with the end times.
No, no. Notice that “prophetic” here does not mean speaking about the future. It means proclaiming the truth in the present. The prophets spoke to their own times and proclaimed God's truth, not merely future events.
So instead of the word “prophetic,” perhaps we could use another word...
We could say bold – speaking with boldness before the world.
Good.
Truth in everything.
Yes, yes. Boldness. Proclaiming the truth.
If the Church does not speak the truth, who will? Isn't that so?
We are all looking for something to rely on, and when we have a spiritual father, we rely on him.
Most politicians will not follow the truth of Christ. Do not expect them to. Leave them aside. But we, as the Church, must speak the truth. If we fail to speak the truth, we will have to answer for it. And the consequences will be serious – for us, for our flock, and for the world.
Unity in Truth
As we approach the end of our conversation, I would say that a united Church would offer a much stronger and more enduring witness to the truth in the eyes of laypeople, who would no longer see divided groups.
Unity in truth. Not simply the Orthodox Church... Do not frame it that way.
Yes. But even among ourselves, there are often...
Yes, we must have Orthodox unity, but unity in truth – among Orthodox Christians.
Exactly. Someone must take a step back and ask forgiveness, as you said at the beginning.
Yes. But forgiveness, I repeat, must be grounded in the consensus of the Holy Fathers and in Tradition. That is how we demonstrate obedience. Otherwise, we will never achieve unity. Unity means that all of us follow and obey the Holy Fathers – not only the Fathers of the fourth or fifth centuries, but also the saints of our own time, those who lived recently.
That is how you become someone who “follows the Holy Fathers”: by following St. Paisios, St. Porphyrios, St. Iakovos, and other recent saints. That is why I cited St. Paisios in connection with the coronavirus.
It is not difficult, my friends. It is a matter of determination, faithfulness, and humility. That is our problem. It is a spiritual problem.
If someone asks forgiveness without those commitments, it will be forgiveness for personal advantage, and he will eventually return to his old ways.
Yes. For many people, it would be a lie. Very little would change.
When will Elder Ephraim be canonized?
One final question: when do you think Elder Ephraim will be canonized? In everyone's hearts, he is already a saint. We do not need official recognition.
He is a saint. That is a good and important question. God knows when. But according to the Church's Tradition, we should not rush. If you look at the whole history of the Church, it may take 20, 30, 50, or even 100 years. St. Nikodemos the Hagiorite was glorified more than a century after his repose, even though he performed miracles every day.
I do not know whether that is a guarantee or a sign. What I mean is that recognition by the Patriarchate is the final step, following recognition by the people and by God. And we already have that: recognition of his holiness by the people of God and the testimony of numerous miracles from God. So we could hurry and say, “Let it happen sooner.”
But we should not. We should not because – and I am afraid this may sound rather harsh – there are interests that favor a quick canonization.
There are interests involved in having it happen quickly?
Yes. And I do not want those interests to overshadow the elder's genuine holiness.
Interests in a quick canonization? Why? After all, canonizations often happen quickly.
Because when a bishop recognizes someone as a saint, he gains authority from doing so.
I see.
I have an interest in recognizing him because people will love me, since they love the saint. Do you understand? We must not allow that to become mixed up with the saint's pure image. But God permits even this and arranges things so that, despite people's interests, everything can still be blessed. He is already a saint. You know, for 1,400 years, there was not even a formal process of canonization.
When did that begin?
About 300 years ago. I do not know exactly when it started. But for a thousand years, all those saints – St. Nicholas and the others – had no formal canonization by councils.
How did it happen? People composed services, painted icons, and venerated the saints. So the elder is already a saint. From the moment the people accept him and God bears witness through miracles, he is a saint.
Let official recognition come whenever it comes.
In God's good time.
In God's good time.
A message to young people
Please give us your blessing. I could ask you to say something to everyone about peace of mind or anger. But if you agree, I would like you to offer a word of advice to young people – our youth, the future of every country, not just Greece, because Orthodoxy is universal.
They must reflect deeply on the meaning of life and love the truth above everything else. If they do that, sooner or later God will guide their steps along the path of the saints, and they will be freed from the spirit of this age. Let them learn to hate the things that enslave them in our time. They must understand that the nihilism of our age is their enemy. That is what we are experiencing – nihilism. Apostasy, all of this, this entire way of life – so many things fall under the nihilism of our age.
The first step is to recognize that I am living within this atmosphere and that I want to be free of it. I want to be liberated. I do not want to be confined by my age. I want to rise above it and become a true human being, free from all these chains. And they will find that freedom only in Christ.
Let them love Christ and pray to Christ that their love for His Person and for the truth may grow, so that they may live for the truth alone.
And to young men who want to become priests, I say: “You want to become a priest? Very good. But be prepared to endure persecution. Be prepared for difficulties. “For the love of Christ and the truth, do what God wants, wherever He may lead you. “Do not enter the priesthood as though it were a job or a position. Enter it only for Christ, only for the truth of Christ.” Young men like that will become very strong. They will become martyrs – whether through their blood or simply through their witness – and they will help a great many people.
Today is a wonderful time to be a priest, but it requires tremendous courage, and it is difficult. You will encounter many challenges, and that is very good for your sanctification. You will face many difficulties, and through them, little by little, step by step, you will become holy by following the Holy Fathers. But you must make a firm decision: nothing stands above the truth. For no reason will I serve anything else. If you live that way, you will help a great many people.
[Laughs.] I wish the same for you.
God grant it.


